ENGLISH VERSION: Russias Extremism Law Violates Human Rights. A video deemed offensive to the MP was ruled «extremist» by a city court in Vladimir, chief editor of «Portal-Credo.Ru» Alexander Soldatov now could also be tried for extremism — Credo.Press

ENGLISH VERSION: Russias Extremism Law Violates Human Rights. A video deemed offensive to the MP was ruled "extremist" by a city court in Vladimir, chief editor of "Portal-Credo.Ru" Alexander Soldatov now could also be tried for extremism

Last Friday, a video deemed offensive to the Moscow Patriarchate of the Russian Orthodox Church was ruled "extremist" by a city court in Vladimir. While Alexander Soldatov — chief editor of Credo.ru, the website that posted the offending video — now could also be tried for extremism, the real defendants should be Russia's extremism law and the officials who are helping expand its reach and influence across the country.

The charge should be violating religious freedom and related rights of Russia's religious minorities or anyone who offends or competes with Russia's dominant church.

The video, which Soldatov posted last year, shows court bailiffs attempting to seize religious relics from a parish of the independent Russian Orthodox Autonomous Church and includes words that are critical of Moscow Patriarchate representatives. The Autonomous Church had been given these relics when it separated from the Moscow Patriarchate in 1988.

Russia first enacted its extremism law in 2002, partly in response to concerns about terrorism. But the law, which prescribes sanctions on those promoting the "exclusivity, superiority or inferiority of citizens" based on religion, was broadened in 2007 to include even nonviolent actors, thus reaching far beyond any fears of extremism linked to terrorism.

As of the release of this year's annual report of the U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom, Russia's list of materials banned as extremist had reached 2,241 items. Merely possessing banned works can trigger fines, while the mass distribution, preparation or storage of such materials can result in a four-year prison term.

Which Russians are most affected by the extremism law? First and foremost, it is the country's Muslims, who often are wrongly labeled security threats — a serious error — which along with various forms of repression can lead to the very radicalization that officials are claiming to combat under the guise of the extremism law.

A court in 2007 banned the Russian translations of 14 Quran commentaries by Turkish theologian Said Nursi, due to his assertion of Islam's exclusivity, not because of any security threats.

Examples of other banned texts are a sermon delivered more than a century ago in 1900 by Metropolitan Sheptytsky, a candidate for Catholic sainthood; and at least 70 Jehovah's Witness texts.

In August 2013, Russia banned the entire international website of the Jehovah's Witnesses because it contained phrases from previously prohibited brochures. Examples of these phrases include "what the Bible teaches," "draw near unto Jehovah" and "come follow me."

In early 2014, a regional court overturned this ruling, ending Russia's embarrassment of being the only nation in the world to ban the pacifist group's website.

Clearly, concerns about terrorism and other security matters don't fully explain either the content of Russia's extremism law or its application. A fuller explanation must include Russia's tendency to target groups that appear to challenge what many officials, including President Vladimir Putin, proclaim is the Moscow Patriarchate's role as sole guardian of Russia's cultural identity. Other religious groups have no place in this cultural identity, and so they are not protected.

This tendency would explain why the law allows officials to target nonviolent citizens who threaten no one. It would explain the prosecution of human rights blogger Maxim Yefimov in the Karelia region after he criticized the Moscow Patriarchate in December 2011. And of course, it would explain why Alexander Soldatov risks being prosecuted today for a video that offended the Russian Orthodox Church.

Partly because of its extremism law and its application, Russia's government remains on the U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom's Tier-2 list of serious violators of freedom of religion or belief.

In monitoring religious freedom abuses in various countries, the U.S. commission applies international human rights standards included in such documents as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.

We are not alone in our conclusion. Based on these same standards, the European Union reiterated in March of this year its strong opposition to the extremism law. Two years ago, in June 2012, the Council of Europe's Venice Commission reached the same conclusion.

The Venice Commission — composed of independent experts on constitutional law — stated that Russia's extremism law lacked clarity, invited arbitrary application and was overly broad, thus violating international law.

Coupled with the alarming erosion of other human rights in Russia, particularly since Putin's return to the presidency, the extremism law and its chilling application raise a disturbing question.

Do fundamental freedoms, including freedom of religion or belief, have a future in Russia? How Russia ultimately handles people like Soldatov and his website may help provide the answer to this question.

Katrina Lantos Swett, Robert P. George,

"The Moscow Times", 26.11.2014

Foto: Vedomosti

Опубликовано: 01.12.2014 в 15:36

Рубрики: English version, Лента новостей



Пожалуйста, поддержите "Портал-Credo.Ru"!

Всего комментариев: 0

Оставить комментарий

Ваш email не будет опубликован.

В сюжете:

Главные новости

МЫСЛИ: Александр Зорин. КОГДА ВОЗРОДИТСЯ СВЯТАЯ РУСЬ? Проповедь среднеуральского старца

«Предлагаю страдающим духовной проказой, предлагающим русскому народу самоизоляцию… выселить их по выбору в Биробиджан…» (Схиигумен Сергий (Романов) Команда сверху нам ...
Подробнее

МОНИТОРИНГ СМИ: "Очень просим многоуважаемых верующих, паломников не приходить к нам в село...". Великорецкий крестный ход РПЦ МП пройдет без... людей

Пока митрополит Вятский и Слободской Марк (Тужиков) рассылает по епархиям письма с робкой просьбой не приезжать на Великорецкий крестный ход, ...
Подробнее

По предварительным данным, в реанимации находился протодиакон Владимир Назаркин

Помощник председателя ОВЦС МП, выполняющий функцию старшего диакона на большинстве служб Патриарха Кирилла (Гундяева) протодиакон Владимир Назаркин с супругой находились ...
Подробнее

Полностью сгорел храм на подворье Троице-Сергиевой лавры в Гремячем

На территории скита Троице-Сергеевой лавры на Гремячем ключе под Сергиевым Посадом ранним утром 23 мая произошёл сильный пожар. Загорелась деревянная ...
Подробнее

МНЕНИЕ: Протодиакон АНДРЕЙ КУРАЕВ: «Неспособность церковного сознания учиться на своих собственных катастрофах ставит серьёзные вопросы...»

Фрагменты из интервью Александру Солдатову на канале “Новой газеты” Начало — ЗДЕСЬ… Продолжение — ЗДЕСЬ… Александр Солдатов: Справедливо ли утверждать, что ...
Подробнее

МОНИТОРИНГ СМИ: Стены все стерпят. После изъятия Путина и Сталина из «главного храма» ВС РФ в нем осталось еще немало спорного

«Спор о вере»: за и против Сталина После ожесточенных интернет-сражений «православной общественности» в середине мая руководство РПЦ договорилось с руководством ...
Подробнее

От коронавируса скончался монах закрытого на карантин Верхотурского монастыря РПЦ МП

Насельник Свято-Николаевском Верхотурского мужского монастыря РПЦ МП в Свердловской области монах Пимен (Шуваев) скончался от коронавирусной инфекции, сообщает 22 мая ...
Подробнее

Скончался профессор Анатолий Красиков - видный религиовед, бывший руководитель пресс-службы Бориса Ельцина

"Сегодня ушёл от нас Анатолий Андреевич Красиков. 88 лет. Царствие ему небесное", - написал вечером 21 мая в своем блоге ведущий ...
Подробнее

АРХИВ: Исторические параллели: грипп 1900 года в США. Второе посещение епископом Тихоном (Беллавиным) Аляски

28 июня/11 июля 1900 г. «Остановившись на ночлег, встретили человека, направляющегося из Икогмюта на реку Кускоквим. От него узнали, что ...
Подробнее